It is the same gun, the same action and the same features, either way. The Vinci still loads more smoothly. Been shopping around for a new shotgun and Went to the local gun store the other day. I like the classic look of the Montefeltro vs the Beretta. The gas system is incredibly simple and innovative. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. If you get the ethos, report back on your findings. Inertia vs gas! I started looking around and found a new Ben UL 28 in stock, called the guy up and ordered it. Behind her was Fox, another GSP, also locked up and honoring Heidis point. After we approached, Scott had one of the Labs we were hunting with move in to flush the bird. Talk about 20 28 gauge & .410 bore shotguns here. Then I discovered the Fabarm shotguns (made in Italy) - my first glance was their over and under (ELOS Deluxe)but it didn't fit me well. Softest and most reliable gas auto I have ever owned, and I have owned them all. The bird (my third from this one pass) dropped immediately, shedding some feathers on its way down. It didnt take much of the Labs lumbering antics for the bird to decide it was time to get out of Dodge. In a rush of commotion, the pheasant flushed from the grass and made a beeline to the left. remain current: Performance While above average, with the forearm and buttstock even matched in color and tone, it is only that, looking pretty sad compared the wood of the Fabarm XLR5 LR, the Browning Citori 725 20 gauge Field, the Weatherby SA-08 28 gauge, several Ithaca Model 37s and so forth. I have a Beretta A300 which fits into the midrange price-wise. My 28ga UL always works reguardless of conditions and I only clean it about once per year before dove season and hunt it hard all fall and winter for dove, pheasants, quail, ducks and even geese. Weighing just a touch more than 5 pounds, its a real treat to carry all day through the field. by toasty April 19th, 2021, 12:18 pm, Post Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. Manage Settings Sadly, the Ethos trigger is worse, breaking at 6-1/4 pounds or a bit more. Benelli does make a nice shotgun though, no doubt about that. I have a 28ga Ben UL for about 8 years and have shot probably 8-10K rounds out of it with 1/2 of them being hunting. Light, high build-quality, innovative design (easy breakdown and cleaning) and, yes, beautiful wood. This is the world's lightest semi-auto shotgun. Light little booger! There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. The Ethos begs to be offered in 20 gauge, where loading difficulty is far more prominent, and the entire line of Benelli inertia guns (excepting the Vinci) can benefit from better shell handling, a bit larger bolt release, a better magazine cap, and absolutely certain reliability with at least 1 oz. Continue with Recommended Cookies. I love both of my 12 and 20 gauge benelli ethos. With the basic Ethos Performance & security by Cloudflare. Ultra-reliable Inertia Driven system Featherweight alloy receiver Lighter magazine tube Super-strong, super-light carbon fiber rib Crio barrel and choke tubes Inertia-Driven System The Ethos trigger break is just marginally lighter than the weight of the gun and that is a disappointment. Shop SuperSport Starting Price $2,949, Performance Similarly, its Easy-Loading system uses a beveled loading port, redesigned carrier and a two-part carrier latch for simpler loading. It also only came with 2 chokes, no fiber optic sight and the receiver is just regular steel instead of case hardened. no unwanted weight to the back end. Last year I handled multiple versions of the benelli and beretta 20 gauge autos and I went with the Montefeltro. The one caveat to this, of course, is that you have to have an ammo manufacturer that produces 3-inch 28-gauge shells, and at the time, none of the major manufacturers had been. Sport Shotgun Starting Price $2,439, Vinci far more prominent, and the entire line of Benelli inertia guns (excepting "Tolerance and apathy are the last virtues of a dying society." Benelli is a bit more generous with choke tubes with the Ethos than many hunting shotguns, supplying five of them, as opposed to the typical three. Truly impressive for a 28-gauge. find them. Factory one ounce loads are more plentiful, less costly and other prior Benellis have all handled them. Any chance they have 20ga UL for same? The same was promised with the Benelli Vinci, all kinds of extended magazine tubes and easy to switch in modules. Instead of using a traditional blued-steel vent rib soldered on the barrel, the Benelli ETHOS incorporates an interchangeable carbon-fiber rib. If you ever strip one down, examine the few parts and you will wonder how they can be so expensive Reply B BobK Registered Joined Feb 5, 2005 11,042 Posts My experience thus far has been great and it should be on your "must see" list before you settle for something elseI'm glad I did. by PawleysJim April 9th, 2021, 6:06 pm, Post The 28-gauge shotgun is relatively rare in comparison to 12- and 20-gauges, which tend to see the bulk of field use, and ammo can sometimes be difficult to find. ), at essentially the same weight as the Ethos, has an excellent recoil pad, but it sure wasn't enough. Ultra Light. My kids shoot 1oz of #9s at turkeys all the time and they do great. I really don't think fouling will ever result in a jam, unlike all the slip ring on magazine tube systems. and get close to good O/U territory. However, the Grade AA Walnut is generously over-graded on the tested article. Franchi Affinity 3 Upland What Gauge to get? Benelli ; Montefeltro vs. UltraLight 20ga question Montefeltro vs. UltraLight 20ga question. ), 20-gauge (5.2 lbs.) Whoa heck of a price! Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. I currently have a Yildiz O/U that works well but feel more comfortable with an auto loader. THE With its feather-light weight and easy to handle design, you can shoot hundreds of shells all day long without fatigue, making the sport of shooting an enjoyable experience again. Shop Cordoba Starting Price $2,829, Legacy In the case of the 12 gauge Benelli Ultra Light (6 lbs. Most people can't figure out how to shoot light guns, or they "don't understand why 12ga shells are bigger but 28ga cost more". Benelli made a bold decision by bringing out a 28-gauge model of its Ethos shotgun, especially with a 3-inch chamber. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. 2014 by Randy Wakeman. by pacecars April 17th, 2021, 8:41 pm, Post All rights reserved. by cutt down April 10th, 2021, 10:46 am, Post The Ultra Light features a featherweight alloy receiver, shortened magazine tube, and a super-strong, super-light, carbon-fiber rib. The Ethos is a lightweight field gun, quite comfortable with one ounce loads, but not as soft shooting as the Vinci. Benelli 28 Gauge Perfect for youth hunters or shooters of smaller stature, the Benelli 28 gauge for sale is the master of the pheasant field. Is the Benelli worth the extra $400 over the Beretta? It may not display this or other websites correctly. It will be used for Turkey, doves, quail, skeet etc what are the pros and cons of each? Just like the original 12-gauge Ethos, the new 20-gauge is a winner. Ruger Unveils Silent-SR ISB Integrally Suppressed Barrel, New Ammo: Federal Premium Ammunition Introduces Four New Lines, Vudoo Three 60 Review: Precision Over Plinking. Of course, this new Ethos also incorporates Benellis dependable and clean Inertia Driven operating system. Look at the Benelli ethos in the blued version. by msalm April 18th, 2021, 9:15 pm, Post Ultra-reliable Inertia Driven system Featherweight alloy receiver Lighter magazine tube Super-strong, super-light carbon fiber rib Crio barrel and choke tubes ACCOKEEK, Md. all of these issues have attempted to be addressed with the exception Truly deserves a look and at about $750 it is half the price of many. looking shotgun, lacking the horrible fake plasti-wood dipped finishes It features an inertia driven system, red-bar front and metal bead mid-sight, featherweight alloy receiver, lighter magazine tube, tough yet light carbon fiber rib, satin walnut stock with WeatherCoat, and Crio barrel and choke tubes. Aug 22, 2017. by 2nd100 April 10th, 2021, 7:58 pm, Post Two of three arrived cracked and the third one I was able to destroy myself with no effort. I'm in the same boat as you, I need a 12 ga. backup/turkey gun and I want it with a 24' barrel. by pacecars April 30th, 2021, 1:39 am, Post Benelli 12ga ETHOS. It was the perfect shot opportunity for me, and I quickly shouldered my gun, drew down on the bird and shot, making sure to swing through. Slight hikack. By pdave December 22, 2008 in Benelli. The softest shooting gun was the eight pound Remington Versa Max (by a huge margin), followed by the seven pound, one ounce Benelli Vinci, with the lighter Ethos coming in dead last. I currently own just the 12/26 in the ultralight line. Any inertia gun fires just like a fixed breech gun, there is nothing there to attenuate recoil. price will likely be nose-bleed. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. I have a mossberg 500, and a Stoeger 3000. JavaScript is disabled. Weight: 5.3 lbs. A bigger chamber translates to a bigger shell, which can equate to more shot, increased velocity, et cetera. After 8 years now, it is pretty beat up, but it is 1 of 2 shotguns I will never part with. This allows the user to do a couple of things. and 28-gauge (5.0 lbs. The Benelli ComforTech stock approach (Vinci, M2) really does work and impressively softens the recoil pulse: one of the rare gimmicks that works. I don't have anywhere close to me that deals benelli's so i'm sort of flying blind. The "blink" system in the beretta is smooth & reliable. This design has proven itself as inherently reliable over the years, and it certainly did so again during the course of our hunt. It also features an enlarged bolt release, an outward-angled cartridge drop lever and an ergonomic trigger guard and safety for gloved users. 5 lead shot and were cruising along at 1,300 fps. sell. . The Ethos does not have the "Weathercoat" fake wood of the Ultra Light and retains the carbon fiber rib. I load my own TSS and they are roll crimped, Benelli Ultralight 28ga is my favorite gun period. Benelli partnered with shotgun expert Rob Roberts to custom build the Performance Shop ETHOS Upland shotgun. After researching and reading numerous incredibly positive reviews by gun "experts", I purchased a Grey Hunter. My Benelli Ultra Light comes in at 4.9lbs unloaded amd is a breeze to carry in the field. THE by tailcracken pointer Sun Aug 28, 2016 8:27 pm, Powered by phpBB Forum Software phpBB Limited. It isn't as invasive as on the M2 (I happily snapped mine off and threw it away), nor does it obliterate the front bead as on the new A5 Hunter (extracted, garbage can again), but is tolerable, along the lines of the center bead on my Vinci that I've learned to ignore. Just a matter of time before one of the manufacturers brings out a "turkey version" 28ga semi. Get 12 Issues a year of the country's best firearms writing. The very light shell reliability Both are fine guns, the beretta is prettier, but I like the weight of the 28ga UL better for hunting, but shot the xplor very well for clays becuase of the increased weight and a little longer barrel. When I reviewed the Benelli Ultra Light, I found the trigger adequate, breaking at 5 pounds 7 ounces. The Benelli options This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. I was initially skeptical before the hunt, but after having used these shells for three days and dropping a slew of birds with themsome at pretty fair distancesI have to say, Im a believer. loads. My son killed a turkey last week with a 1oz #9 load that is loaded down for low recoil. by WV Ridge Reaper April 18th, 2021, 8:59 pm, Post At $2,199, its price is a little steep for some hunters. I had a Franchi 48 AL but made the mistake of selling it. Apex also makes 28ga TSS shells if you don't reload. Picked up my A400 yesterday! It's a tough call, and only you can decide. It is a very good Talk about light and handy! The shotgun with the best factory trigger was the Vinci, with the Ethos trigger excessively heavy by comparison. It looked to me like Benelli has essentially killed off at least modular Vinci approach where a new buttstock (pistol grip), extra pads, Including the 28ga. To view the purposes they believe they have legitimate interest for, or to object to this data processing use the vendor list link below. Benelli Ethos 28 Type: Semi-auto, Inertia-Driven Gauge: 28 Ga. Chamber: 3 in. The beretta gas system is supposed to be different than previous models & it's supposed to cycle even dirty. UGLYThe Ethos begs to be offered in 20 gauge, where loading difficulty is As mentioned, the tested BUL cycled 7/8 oz. I shot mine all duck season w/o cleaning it. Benelli 12ga Ultra Light. Functioned flawless. 8 On-Target Concealed Carry Insurance Options (2022), 10 Affordable Double-Barrel Shotgun Options (2022), Best AR-15 Options For Any Budget And Buyers Guide (2022), Best Concealed Carry Handguns For Women (2022). Other than that it is the same as the regular L that goes for $1100-1200 so I thought that was a heck of a deal. The Ethos has been touted as super-easy to load the magazine. Target loads are often more available due to the 28-gauges frequent use in skeet shooting. Winchester "Super Speed" promo loads with no malfunctions at all. by msalm April 22nd, 2021, 11:50 am, Post Just received my new UL 28 ga this morninggoing to like this one. Then I heard about and finally handled one of their new 4LS auto-loading shotguns. by jsh909 May 2nd, 2021, 3:47 pm, Powered by phpBB Forum Software phpBB Limited. I'm not sure which one I'd go for. Sights: Interchangeable fiber optic (red, yellow, green) MSRP: $2,199 Manufacturer: Benelli USA. I ended up going with the Ultra light 28ga got one new out the door for 1150 and shot almost 400 Winchester AA through it yesterday here at the FT Bragg Clay Target Center an Boy is it an Absolute Dream to shoot!!!! If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. Benelli 12ga Legacy. I have them in 28 and 12, lightest autos on the planet. Copyright 2014 by Randy Wakeman. -Aristotle, The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo, Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group), 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA. by pacecars April 10th, 2021, 8:18 pm, Post This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. Benelli, for some inexplicable reason, still puts a center bead on hunting guns. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. TSS makes the 28ga a beast in the turkey woods! yesterday at Sportsman Warehouse, man what a sweet little gun. to most Benellis and also that it costs way too much. This article is an excerpt from the January 2017 issue of Gun Digest the Magazine. BADThe retail price points of $2200 and $2000 open up many other options By comparison, this Benelli is simpler, far stronger, and has better shot capacity. In the felt recoil department, there was no doubt. of number two. The 28-gauge has typically occupied a sort of niche in the shotgun world, being more limited to target shooting and hunting smaller game birds while the larger gauges see the lions share of use. The hardest safety to get off was also on the Ethos. bolt into battery (enabling the Benelli Click), 4) you can't Performance & security by Cloudflare. The Benelli Vinci is more comfortable to shoot than the Ethos. The notion of The ugly isn't about The elegant and reliable shotgun combines traditional form with innovative refinements to create the perfect balance of art and . Debuting at the 2016 SHOT Show, the Ethos 28-gauge was an expansion of the manufacturers already popular Ethos shotgun line, which included 12- and 20-gauge models. I am a lefty so that is making me lean towards the Monte. The Ethos trigger break is just marginally lighter than the weight of the gun and that is a disappointment. Borrowed my dads when i returned home for a visit and was nailing them left and right. The felt recoil has http://randywakeman.com/ReviewBenelliEthos12GaugeAutoloader.htm The Ethos is a light gun, very light for a 12 gauge, and only a quarter pound heavier than the shorter-barreled (24 inch) Benelli Ultra Light 12 gauge. I own the a400 xplor. However, just as assembled out of the box, the 26 inch barrel Ethos weighs 6 pounds, 7 ounces via calibrated electronic scale. The heavy trigger, heavy safety and heavy price all combine to make the Ethos a lackluster shotgun, not comparing favorably to Benelli's own M2 and Vinci as a general hunting shotguns, both which retail for $500 - $600 less and are a lot more fun to shoot. The Ethos promised to cycle 7/8 ounce loads, which I'd never use out of a 12 gauge hunting gun. Well, I was all ready to buy the Beretta A500 but then I saw the Benelli Ethos Cordoba with the BeST finish. Now, if I did a lot of goose hunting with 3 1/2s, Id start looking real hard at the Beretta, but for 12 gauge 3 inch and 20 gauge, I love the Benellis. Sadly, the Ethos trigger is worse, breaking at 6-1/4 pounds or a bit more. It's worthless on a hunting gun, for a pheasant hunter that thinks he needs to \'93check his gun mount\'94 is going to go hungry. Benelli 12ga Montefeltro (2011 to current production) . I've had 5 ultralights. If you want to have a brand new shotgun, I understand that, that's cool, there's lots out there. You are using an out of date browser. GOODThe shell-handling, particularly the ease of unloading has been improved, If you're shooting several hundred rounds in a single outing, the recoil can get to be harsh. You can look for a Legacy in 28ga as well. Most have never appeared after five years. 51.68.115.32 Your IP: ARCHIVED; Posted: 10/9/2022 2:25:22 PM EST . The new Browning A5 Hunter (6-1/2 lbs. You might expand your thinking and searching to include older guns, just a thought. At $2,199 the Ethos 20-gauge isn't cheap, but it's certainly . No malfunctions, but the Vinci did fail to cycle these shells a couple of times. I ended up getting a Franchi Instinct L at my local Scheels for $699.99 (849.99 regular). This follows the Both the Vinci and the Versa Max had dream safeties by comparison. I had a super 90 a couple years back that I wasn't super fond of as far as fit was concerned, but it was very reliable. JavaScript is disabled. Light, high build-quality, innovative design (easy breakdown and cleaning) and, yes, beautiful wood. Previously, a shooter wouldve had to manually cycle and eject each shell through the ejection port. Drew Warden is a past Managing Editor of Gun Digest the Magazine. Your own eyes can be the judge of that. a better magazine cap, and absolutely certain reliability with at least And, IMO, it's a better looking gun. cats, motorcycle sketches, violins, and costumed batgirls. With 1-1/8 ounce loads, the difference was more pronounced. Hunting Dog Training, Gun Dog Puppies, and Discussion, Post It was also a perfect complement to the classy upland gear provided by Banded for our hunt. We and our partners use cookies to Store and/or access information on a device. Click to reveal This is the world's lightest semi-auto shotgun, offered in 12-, 20-, and 28-gauge. I have a Benelli Super Eagle from about 1997 give or take that I like and do not NEED a new one but I do want one. The concept seems to make sense. Which ever gun feels the best. You can email the site owner to let them know you were blocked. Post The Benelli Ultra Light 20GA is a super lightweight semi-automatic shotgun. It just felt natural when I picked it up and compared it to a couple other guns. It was the stock version that came in a cardboard box instead of a case. While this graceful design may keep avid waterfowl hunters from tossing the Ethos in their duck blind, the guns svelte feel and sophisticated appearance are perfectly suited for upland hunters. Now, Ive shot the Berretta and its an awesome gun. I have shot the xplor 28ga once. The consent submitted will only be used for data processing originating from this website. A few short seconds later the dogs had retrieved it, and on we went. Outstand and beautiful guns. I looked at the Montefeltro and Ultralight and both look and feel awesome. I saw other writers knock down pheasants at distances approaching 60 yards, and I myself dropped one at what Id estimate as close to 50 yards. Most of the depends on gauge - I will assume 12 for now,,,,,. A big part of my decision was how it looked and pointed for me. more commentary than anything else in the category, even though the Benelli And, because its a 28-gauge, that lightness doesnt punish you once its time to shoot. The Ethos uses the same Crio choke tubes found on other Benelli shotguns, which Ive always found to be very good. #1. It is not only small, but overly stiff. The Ethos 28-gauge is an incredibly lightweight, smooth-swinging game gun. 870 12ga of a browning citori, those browning are incledibly good handling if they are a touch heavy. loads. I went with the Montefeltro today. Get the one that fits you best. Overview Benelli Ultra Light Satin Walnut 28 Gauge 2-3/4in Semi Automatic Shotgun - 26in - The Ultra Light shotgun is an upland hunter's dream. Your IP: Hunting Mule Deer: Theres an App for That! A word to the wise is make sure you like the shotgun as supplied, for the dreams of easy customization and accessorization (pads, comb inserts, length of pull kits) all too often remain vaporware. What precisely all Ultra Lights will cycle with as a minimum I really can't say. 6) they are ugly, and 7) they don't do well with light loads, In the Ethos, You can email the site owner to let them know you were blocked. I'm hoping that by going with a newer model ie the BUL or monte the shims can work out my fit issue and I will still get the same reliability of my old super 90. at $1999 MSRP, the nickel at $2199, all of the above models (that lack Benellis seem either obsolete, pricey, or ugly. Apr 9, 2021. Posted: 10/9/2022 2:42:17 . Again, it can be considered a minor improvement, but it is the 20 gauges (M2, Affinity) that are in need of significant help in the stiff loading department, not the 12 gauge Benellis. loads. Save my name and email to use for future comments. The general problems While the Ethos discards the inline action of the Vinci, Benellis decision to introduce a 28-gauge offering was an interesting one in and of itself. as a hunting (or considerations) with Benellis, in general, have long been 1) Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. Benelli will not guarantee reliability with light loads, and they are up front about it. Get the 76th edition of the World's Greatest Gun Book. I always thought the SX3 was on the lighter side for a 12ga. Type of Sights: Red-Bar Front and Metal Bead Mid-Sight, Minimum Recommended Load: 2-1/2 dram, 7/8 oz. The ethos being the exception. I did not buy either but leaning towards the Monty. a 20 gauge monti and it didnt fit. that are impossible to touch up or match. It kicks less and is heavier (Im pretty sure on the heavier, but not certain). It feels so good in my hands. I'd buy used. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. Cloudflare Ray ID: 78bb83a81f9990bb by codym Thu Feb 12, 2015 8:48 pm, Post The Benelli Ultra Light is a super lightweight semi-automatic shotgun.It features an inertia driven system, red-bar front and metal bead mid-sight, featherweight alloy receiver, lighter magazine tube, tough yet light carbon fiber rib, satin walnut stock with WeatherCoat, and Crio barrel and choke tubes.. Benelli 12ga M2/M2 Tactical. The direct acting shotguns with the Benelli system kick like a mule. System" would have been more aptly named "Progressive Discomfort." It is a better-looking alternative, as well, by most standards. ), are the lightest semi-automatic shotguns in production for their respective gauges. Come join the discussion about optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! I have a Benelli Super Eagle from about 1997 give or take that I like and do not NEED a new one but I do want one. I was in your situation about three years ago and looked at all the major brands including Browning, Benelli, Winchester, Remington, and some not so well known brands. Benelli 12ga Vinci. You have entered an incorrect email address! It also comes equipped with three interchangeable fiber optic front sights for use in any lighting condition a shooter might face in the field. There is not a better functioning 28ga auto on the market than the benelli. It will be used for Turkey, doves, quail, skeet etc what are the pros and cons of each? At the time, I was able to purchase it for just over $1300 so it may be at the top edge of your budget. As it turns out, though, the Ethos has after going to a profesional gun fitter it was discovered that either the M2 or ultra light fit me perfectly, A thousand dollar mistake but one you dont have to make . Works, does everything it is supposed to do but just didn't like it. several key features of the Ethos) are suddenly a really, really hard Up ahead, Heidi, a veteran German Shorthaired Pointer (GSP), was rooted in place, clipped tail rigid in the air, front leg bent and nose straight as an arrow pointing at the edge of a tall grass patch, where yet another pheasant was surely hunkered down. 3 oz. by pacecars April 9th, 2021, 6:59 am, Post If you want to change the rib height, it is easy to do. Benelli has reworked the action. An example of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie. not been dramatically reduced with the Progressive Comfort Actually, the easiest, smoothest loading shotgun of the three was the Benelli Vinci, though none were difficult. Jeff from Indiana"has a buddy that swears by 28ga"! This can be especially true for suitable field loads. Ive never been around one, The man who passes the sentence should swing the sword. The stock is walnut and attractive, with well-cut checkering. Where the Ethos delivers is better, more positive ejection with extremely light loads than prior Benellis. The stock is walnut and attractive, with well-cut checkering. It is also lighter and faster handling.